Experts worldwide are suggesting a new approach to define and diagnose obesity, aiming to improve how we identify people who need help with health issues caused by excess body fat.
The traditional measure, Body Mass Index (BMI), has faced criticism for its limitations. The new method combines BMI with other indicators, like waist size and signs of related health problems, to provide a clearer picture of obesity.
Obesity affects more than a billion people globally. In the United States alone, about 40% of adults are classified as obese, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The goal of the new recommendations, published in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, is to better identify those who need treatment the most.
Dr. David Cummings, an obesity expert from the University of Washington and a co-author of the report, explained that this approach offers a more accurate way to diagnose obesity.
The report introduces two categories: clinical obesity and pre-clinical obesity. People with clinical obesity not only meet BMI and other obesity markers but also show evidence of health problems caused by excess weight.
These might include heart disease, high blood pressure, liver or kidney issues, or joint pain. Treatment options for them could range from lifestyle changes like diet and exercise to medical treatments, including obesity medications.
Those with pre-clinical obesity are at risk of developing similar health issues but do not yet have any significant illnesses. Identifying these individuals early could help prevent future complications.
BMI, a widely used measure, has long been criticized for being too simplistic. It calculates obesity based only on height and weight, often misclassifying individuals. For example, athletes with high muscle mass may have a high BMI despite having normal fat levels.
On the other hand, people with lower BMI might carry unhealthy amounts of body fat. This system doesn’t always reflect the reality of someone’s health.
Under the new criteria, about 20% of people who were previously classified as obese might no longer fit the definition. At the same time, 20% of people with serious health conditions but a lower BMI could now be considered clinically obese.
This shift wouldn’t change the overall percentage of people classified as obese but would ensure those with significant health risks are accurately diagnosed.
More than 75 medical organizations have endorsed these recommendations, but how quickly they will be adopted is uncertain. Updating the criteria could be costly and require additional training for healthcare professionals.
For example, measuring waist size sounds simple but can be tricky. Doctors may use different methods, and some tools, like measuring tapes, might not be suitable for larger patients.
To implement this new system effectively, healthcare providers would need to perform detailed health assessments and lab tests. This makes the process more complex, and some experts believe it might not be easy to adopt widely.
Dr. Katherine Saunders, an obesity specialist at Weill Cornell Medicine, emphasized that the system must be quick, affordable, and reliable to succeed.
Others, like Kate Bauer, a nutrition expert at the University of Michigan, are skeptical. She pointed out that people prefer simple messages, and this new classification might confuse the public rather than help them.
Dr. Robert Kushner, one of the report’s authors, acknowledged that changing how we define obesity will take time. He believes this is just the beginning of an important discussion about better ways to address obesity and its health effects.
Review and Analysis
The study highlights a critical step forward in understanding obesity. By moving beyond BMI, it aims to address the complexity of excess body fat and its health impacts. The new definitions focus on identifying those at higher risk and providing targeted treatment, which could lead to better health outcomes.
However, implementing the recommendations presents challenges. The additional assessments and measurements may require significant resources, training, and time. This could create barriers for widespread adoption, especially in healthcare systems already under strain.
Moreover, public understanding of these changes is crucial. If the new classifications confuse people, they may fail to recognize the importance of early intervention.
Overall, the proposed system represents progress in tackling obesity more effectively, but its success will depend on how well it is implemented and communicated to both healthcare professionals and the public.
If you care about weight management, please read studies about diets that could boost your gut health and weight loss, and 10 small changes you can make today to prevent weight gain.
For more information about obesity, please see recent studies about low-carb keto diet could manage obesity effectively and results showing popular weight loss diet linked to heart disease and cancer.
The research findings can be found in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology.
Copyright © 2025 Knowridge Science Report. All rights reserved.
