Cleveland’s famous sea monster gets a scientific makeover after 90 years

Newly described muscle anatomy (right) and overall jaw anatomy of Dunkleosteus terrelli (center), compared to a more typical arthrodire (left). Credit: Russell Engelman/Case Western Reserve University.

About 360 million years ago, long before dinosaurs walked the Earth, a terrifying predator ruled the shallow seas that once covered what is now Cleveland, Ohio.

Its name was Dunkleosteus terrelli, a massive, armored fish that could grow up to 14 feet long. Instead of teeth, it used sharp, bony blades in its jaws to slice through prey.

With its heavy armor and powerful bite, Dunkleosteus was one of the most fearsome hunters of the Devonian period.

Since its discovery in the 1860s, Dunkleosteus has become a prehistoric superstar.

Its giant skull and jaws are displayed in museums around the world, and it is often shown as the face of ancient sea monsters.

Despite this fame, scientists had not taken a close, modern look at the animal’s anatomy for nearly a century.

Now, an international team of researchers led by Case Western Reserve University has re-examined Dunkleosteus using advanced scientific knowledge and new techniques.

Their study, published in The Anatomical Record, brings this prehistoric predator into the 21st century and reveals that it was more unusual than anyone realized.

The last major study of Dunkleosteus’ jaw was published in 1932. At that time, scientists were still struggling to understand how the bones of these ancient fishes even fit together.

Arthrodires, the group Dunkleosteus belonged to, are difficult to study because much of their skeleton was made of cartilage, which doesn’t fossilize well. Usually, only their armored head and upper body are preserved, often crushed or flattened by time and pressure.

Since then, many better-preserved fossils have been found in other parts of the world, especially in Australia. These discoveries helped scientists understand how arthrodire bodies were structured. Using this new knowledge, the team carefully examined fossils from the Cleveland Museum of Natural History, which holds the best and largest collection of Dunkleosteus remains anywhere.

What they found was surprising. Nearly half of Dunkleosteus’ skull was actually made of cartilage, including important areas where jaw muscles attached. This is far more than scientists once believed. They also discovered a large bony channel in the skull that held a powerful facial muscle, very similar to the jaw muscles found in modern sharks and rays. This provided strong evidence that Dunkleosteus used its muscles in a way that was more advanced and efficient than previously thought.

Even more interesting, Dunkleosteus turned out to be something of an evolutionary oddball. While most of its relatives had actual teeth, Dunkleosteus and a few close species lost their teeth long ago and instead evolved those famous bone blades. These sharp edges allowed them to tear large chunks out of other fish, making them specialized hunters of big prey.

The study also showed that arthrodires were not all simple, primitive creatures, as once believed. They were actually a highly diverse group of fish, filling many different roles in ancient ocean ecosystems.

This new research proves that even the most famous fossils still have secrets to tell. Dunkleosteus, Cleveland’s legendary sea monster, is now understood in a whole new way, reminding us that science is always evolving—just like life itself.