A new study from Aarhus University reveals that when we are uncertain about what to expect, our brain amplifies pain, even if there’s no real threat. The research, published in Science Advances, sheds light on how uncertainty, not just expectation, shapes our pain perception—which could have significant implications for pain management.
How the Brain Reacts to the Unknown
When we accidentally touch something familiar, like a warm pan, our brain already predicts what it will feel like. This expectation helps regulate the sensation, so even if it’s slightly uncomfortable, the pain remains manageable.
However, if we were blindfolded and unaware of what we were touching, we would likely feel more intense pain, even if the pan wasn’t hot enough to cause harm.
To investigate how uncertainty affects pain, researchers designed an experiment where participants were asked to predict whether they would feel a warm or cold sensation on their forearm.
However, at times, they were exposed to both warm and cold stimuli simultaneously, triggering a strange and painful reaction known as the thermal grill illusion—a sensation of burning pain, even though nothing is actually burning the skin.
“Previous studies have shown that our expectations shape pain perception,” said Associate Professor Francesca Fardo, lead researcher of the study. “We wanted to see if uncertainty—when the brain doesn’t have a clear prediction—also plays a role in increasing pain.”
The Role of Uncertainty in Pain Perception
Using brain imaging and computer modeling, the study examined 300 participants and found that when the brain is unsure about what to expect, it intensifies pain as a precautionary response.
Previous research has demonstrated how placebo and nocebo effects influence pain—expecting relief can reduce pain, while expecting harm can increase it. This study adds another layer: uncertainty itself can heighten pain, even without any real physical threat.
“When the brain receives ambiguous signals, it errs on the side of caution, exaggerating the pain response,” Fardo explained.
How This Could Change Pain Management
These findings could help improve pain treatment strategies, especially for anxious patients who fear medical procedures. If doctors and healthcare providers clearly explain what to expect, it may help reduce uncertainty-related pain.
“By setting clear expectations and reducing uncertainty, health professionals may help patients experience less pain,” Fardo said.
Next Steps: Investigating Chronic Pain and Mental Health
Fardo and her team now plan to repeat the study with chronic pain patients to see if the same effects apply. They also want to explore whether mental health conditions like anxiety and depression influence how uncertainty affects pain perception.
This research highlights the power of the mind in shaping pain experiences—not just through expectation, but through the fear of the unknown. Understanding this could lead to better pain management strategies and improved patient care.
If you care about pain, please read studies about how to manage your back pain, and Krill oil could improve muscle health in older people.
For more information about pain, please see recent studies about how to live pain-free with arthritis, and results showing common native American plant may help reduce diarrhea and pain.
Copyright © 2025 Knowridge Science Report. All rights reserved.
