Benefits of fish oil supplements: Are they real?

Credit: Unsplash+.

Fish oil supplements are widely available in pharmacies and are often promoted for their myriad health benefits, which purportedly range from enhancing heart health to boosting cognitive function.

However, recent findings published in JAMA Cardiology have brought the efficacy of these supplements into question.

Analysis of Health Claims

The study conducted by researchers from UT Southwestern Medical School critically examined the health claims associated with fish oil supplements. Out of the 2,819 products they analyzed, a staggering 74% made at least one health claim.

Surprisingly, only 19% of these claims were backed by FDA-approved qualified health claims. The rest offered vague assurances, such as “promotes heart health,” without substantial evidence.

The Omega-3 Paradox

Fish oil’s purported benefits are primarily attributed to omega-3 fatty acids EPA and DHA. Despite their popularity, the study highlighted considerable variations in the daily doses of these omega-3s across different brands.

Furthermore, there are no established dietary recommendations for EPA and DHA from the Office of Dietary Supplements, adding to the confusion about their appropriate intake levels.

Real-world Implications and Expert Opinions

Despite the murky evidence, fish oil supplements remain popular, especially among individuals over 60 who use them to support heart health.

Dr. Ann Marie Navar, co-author of the study, suggests that consumers might be better off investing in more proven health measures such as fresh vegetables or medications that manage blood pressure or cholesterol.

Connie Diekman, a food and nutrition consultant, adds that while eating fish can be beneficial due to its overall nutritional content, the specific health benefits may not necessarily come from the fish oil alone.

She stresses the importance of consulting with healthcare providers and dietitians before starting any supplement regimen.

Call for Better Regulation

The study advocates for stricter regulations on dietary supplement labeling to prevent misleading the public. This call is underscored by findings from two significant trials, VITAL and the UK’s ASCEND, which did not find benefits from fish oil supplements in preventing heart disease.


The increasing body of research questioning the health benefits of fish oil supplements suggests that consumers should approach these products with caution.

Healthcare professionals can provide valuable guidance on whether these supplements are necessary or effective, based on individual health profiles.

This research underscores a broader issue: not all that is claimed on supplement labels is guaranteed in terms of health benefits, highlighting the need for consumer vigilance and informed decision-making.

The study from JAMA Cardiology serves as a reminder that effective health management often requires more than just supplement intake; it necessitates a comprehensive approach that includes dietary and lifestyle changes.

If you care about nutrition, please read studies about how Mediterranean diet could protect your brain health, and the best time to take vitamins to prevent heart disease.

For more information about nutrition, please see recent studies that olive oil may help you live longer, and vitamin D could help lower the risk of autoimmune diseases.

Copyright © 2024 Knowridge Science Report. All rights reserved.